IBAHRI Showcase: the world and its children

Thursday 19 November 2026

This session explored violations against children including displacement, trafficking and exploitation, while considering the legal frameworks and mechanisms intended to protect them and hold perpetrators to account.

Almudena Arpón de Mendívil, Gomez-Acebo & Pombo; Immediate Past President, IBA: Last year, violence against children in war reached devastating new levels, as reported by the United Nations in June 2026. Children are innocent. Children are not statistics. Children suffer first, and they suffer more. And that is why international law grants to them special protections.

Why are children’s rights being increasingly attacked? Why do they suffer more and more? And what can we, the members of the legal profession, do to close the breach between what the law promises to a child and what it delivers?

My dream is to have a world where children’s rights will be protected. And I’m not thinking about a number of generations ahead. Let’s do it in three years. Ambitious, yes, I know. We have the rules, we have the institutions, we need further collective push, and we need more accountability in order to make it real.

Steve Crawshaw, author, Prosecuting the Powerful: I think we do also need to acknowledge the possibilities of change. Some progress has been achieved, and much, much more is needed. It is absolutely important and logical that in international humanitarian law (IHL), in the laws of war, the rules protecting children play an absolutely central role. They’re at the core of IHL. And yet, brazen crimes against children continue. And those are not just in distant conflicts, but here in the continent of Europe also.

Some progress has been achieved, and much, much more is needed

Steve Crawshaw
Author, Prosecuting the Powerful

Theodor Meron, UN War Crimes Tribunals Advisor: For a number of years, I served as an advisor on international humanitarian law to Karim Khan, then-Chief Prosecutor of the ICC. In this capacity, I had the privilege of working on the heartbreaking deportations of Ukrainian children to Russia, including cases of their adoption by Russian families and naturalisation.

Geneva Convention IV, on protection of civilian persons in time of war, contains Article 50 on protection of children, which includes prohibitions of change of personal status and concerns children separated from their parents. Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions contains detailed provisions on protection of children and prohibits the evacuation of children to a foreign country, except temporarily for compelling medical or safety reasons. Violations of this provision constitute a grave breach of the Geneva Conventions.

Saleh, 15, using crutches and holding a Choose Love drawing, Syria. Hand in Hand / Save The Children

Since these violations were committed on Ukrainian soil by Russians, and Ukraine accepted the Rome Statute, Russian perpetrators are subject to ICC jurisdiction. Russia claims that these transfers, or evacuations, have been voluntary. When military activities in a particular area from which children were transferred cease, they must be returned to their previous places of residence. Where Russia claims that material reasons justified transfer to Russia, the burden of proof is on Russia, given the categorical prohibitions. Families may not be separated, and if separated, should be allowed to reunify.

There is the categorical prohibition on change of status through nationalisation or adoption. Repeated efforts to have Russia return the deported Ukrainian children to Ukraine and reunited with their families, including efforts so bravely led by Baroness Kennedy, have, alas, been only partially successful, prolonging the anguish and the tragedy of their families.

Baroness Helena Kennedy LT KC, Director, IBAHRI: There’s a case now going through the European Court of Human Rights, in addition to the International Criminal Court’s warrants, which is going after Russia itself on the basis that human rights abuses have taken place in the taking of the children. And there’s been change of law. Russia has actually now changed the law so that the children who have been taken have their names changed and there can be no pursuit of the history of where they might have come from and so on. They’ve actually changed the law to prohibit it and the argument they make is that this is to protect children as they start new lives, that it shouldn’t be possible for them to have this disturbance of trying to examine their past or where they might have been born and so on. The case is now under way.

Hamza Al-Kateab, Action For Sama: I was working in Aleppo in Syria during the four years of the conflict there and during the siege. The hospital that I was managing was the last remaining hospital in the city. Most hospitals were bombed by the Russians and the Syrian regime, which led them to our final, they call it evacuation, but it’s forced displacement, which is a war crime.

As a doctor, I also saw how much more vulnerable children are to the violence around them. In its work with Save the Children on treating child blast injuries, Imperial College London states, ‘children are seven times more likely to die from blast injuries than adults involved in fighting’. The United Nations Secretary-General has also stated that when explosive weapons are used in populated area, around 90 per cent of those killed and injured are civilians. These figures describe the consequences of decisions about where and how weapons are used.

For the doctor receiving the casualties, they become children who need treatment immediately, often in a hospital that has already lost staff, equipment and supplies. Treating a child requires appropriate expertise and equipment and when those are missing, we do whatever we can. But the loss of a specialist, an ambulance or a functioning operating theatre can affect children who were nowhere near the original attack. And that effect lasts for years.

In Aleppo, parents understood another danger. The hospital itself could be targeted. We see attacks on healthcare far beyond Syria, in Ukraine, Gaza, Sudan, Yemen, and most other conflicts. Perpetrators, unfortunately, learn from each other. And they learn how they can get away with things. In Ukraine alone, the WHO had verified more than 3,000 attacks on healthcare by May this year, since Russia’s full-scale invasion in February 2022. The circumstances of these conflicts differ for sure, but I recognise the consequences are the same. Frightened families, overwhelmed doctors, interrupted treatment, and children losing access to care when they need it most. Deliberately attacking a protected hospital is a war crime. We need to name that clearly and pursue accountability.

Deliberately attacking a protected hospital is a war crime. We need to name that clearly and pursue accountability

Hamza Al-Kateab
Action For Sama

Richard Bennett, United Nations: Five years after the Taliban seized power again, forceful implementation of their oppressive policies is reshaping every aspect of life in Afghanistan, with devastating consequences for children and young people. The Taliban’s institutionalised system of discrimination, repression and ideological control is depriving children of their fundamental rights to education, to express themselves and to participate meaningfully in social and political life. And whatever happens to Afghanistan’s children now will shape the country for decades.

The Taliban’s policies therefore matter not only for the harm they cause today, but for the society they’re creating tomorrow. After five years, the cumulative effect is clear. The Taliban’s unrelenting policies and practises not only violate the human rights of Afghans, they’re reshaping the social fabric of the country. The education system excludes girls and indoctrinates boys.

The Taliban reject the internationally recognised definition of a child as anyone under 18. They’ve dismantled legal frameworks and institutions that once protected children and are exposing Afghan children to violence, abuse and exploitation. At the same time, new directives are further eroding the rights of Afghans. A decree on spousal separation, published this May, appears to recognise marriage involving children and treats any girl who’s attained puberty as eligible. Under these rules, a girl’s silence can be taken as her consent to marriage. Children are being married, sold or given away by families who’ve nothing left. Or who seek to avoid their daughters being forcibly married to Taliban personnel. And not only girls, but boys are also subjected to sexual violence via the ongoing practice of bacha bazi, dancing boys.

The harms to children can’t be understood separately from gender. And the Taliban’s institutionalised and systematic regime of gender-based discrimination, oppression and domination. What the women of Afghanistan, and I, have previously described as gender apartheid is at the core of the Taliban ideology and rule with intergenerational consequences.

I’m also deeply concerned about discrimination against minority, religious and ethnic communities. Afghans’ right to practise their religion is being increasingly constrained. Minority communities are also being targeted on ethnic grounds. Hazara communities appear to be singled out, along with Tajiks, Uzbeks and Turkmen. And after five years, it might be tempting to think about a change in approach. However, neither dialogue with the Taliban nor isolating them appears to make much difference.

I urge states to fund the humanitarian response, support alternative education and safe pathways, and invest in child protection, youth-led initiatives and accountability. I urge the Taliban to end discriminatory policies, restore girls’ access to education and protect children from child marriage, child labour, violence and exclusion, recognising them in their full potential. We must pursue justice that is gender-responsive, survivor-centred and child-centred, whoever the perpetrator and whenever the crime was committed.

Rama, aged 3, holding a drawing, Syria. Hand in Hand / Save The Children

And I call on states to strengthen the available accountability mechanisms. After five years, the Taliban have learned that condemnation without action carries little cost. We must change that. The children of Afghanistan are asking us a simple question: do their rights exist only on paper, or do they mean something in their lives? Our answer must not be another expression of concern or condemnation. It must be action, accountability and solidarity. Their rights are not negotiable. Their childhood cannot wait. And their future cannot be surrendered. If we fail to protect Afghanistan’s children today, we’re not only failing them, we’re failing the very promise of international law and the future it was created to protect.

Gender apartheid is at the core of the Taliban ideology and rule with intergenerational consequences

Richard Bennett
United Nations

Mary Grace Agcaoili, UNICEF: To this date, at least 460 million children, live in conflict-affected areas. Out of these 460 million children, the recent report of the UN Special Representative of the Secretary-General on children affected by armed conflict said that last year alone we recorded the highest number of child victims with verified cases. It kept increasing year in, year out, and you can see from the news why this is so. The second fact that I would like to tell you behind these numbers is for the first time, the cases of violations committed by government forces comprise the majority of these cases. No longer are the other armed groups, the non-state actors, the primary perpetrator of these grave violations of child rights, but it’s the other way around.

The very government forces who are supposed to protect these children have now become the perpetrators of this number of children’s rights violations. The monitoring and reporting mechanism that was established in Security Council Resolution 1612 allowed us, UNICEF, together with other UN agencies in the field to monitor, report and document the cases of grave child rights violations.

What are the six grave child rights violations that we are documenting? The first one is killing and maiming of children. Second would be recruitment and use of children. And again, we are not just talking about child soldiers, children can be used as couriers, as messengers. Third will be rape and other forms of sexual violence. Fourth is abduction of children. And second to the last is attacks on schools, hospitals and other places where children are supposed to access basic health services, including places of worship and other public spaces. The final one is denial of humanitarian access.

Rangita de Silva de Alwis, University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School: At the UN General Assembly’s 81st session, the Secretary-General articulated four defining tests of power. Those four included war, inequality, climate change and AI. And I want to confront the impunity of not just the state actors, but non-state actors. Raphael Lemkin gave name to genocide and also said that war is not fought by arms alone. From Malala to the girls of Chibok, there is a war against girls’ education, and never more than in Afghanistan. In the recent global reckoning by frontier tech leaders sounding the alarm bells and seeking a pause on AI’s inexorable march, I have long asked that we pause before crossing the Rubicon on the deployment of AI-driven lethal autonomous weapon systems in the battlefields. Because once we cross the Rubicon, there is no return.

On asking whether lethal autonomous weapons systems, which operate outside of human control, can comply with international humanitarian laws, principles of distinction, proportionality and precaution, I’m just going to leave you with a simple question: can AI-driven lethal autonomous weapon systems make the distinction between a child playing with a toy gun and a combatant with a gun? Who then is responsible and accountable for mistakes in war when it comes to AI-driven lethal autonomous weapon systems?

Flávia Piovesan, Inter-American Commission on Human Rights: So, violence and inequality do not affect children equally. We have girls, indigenous girls, Afro-descendants, LGBTQI children, children with disabilities and migrants and refugees who suffer intersectional discrimination deep in the violation of children’s rights. In addition to structural challenges, we have three emerging ones: digital, environment and new technologies. On one hand, new technologies promote rights, opening avenues for children’s participation, education and access of information. But on the other hand, new technologies violate rights, exposing childhood to unprecedented risks and threats, such as sexual exploitation, cyberbullying, harmful content, data harvesting, algorithmic profile, and once again, girls suffer an aggravated form of virtual violence.

How does international law protect children’s rights? What are its potential and its limits? And I’d like to focus on the Convention on the Rights of the Child, adopted in 1989, remaining the most widely ratified human rights convention in the history. Today we have 196 states parties, every UN member state but the US. It introduces a new paradigm, shifting from children as objects of protection to children as subjects of rights, deserving special protection, priority, holding civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights, and four key principles: non-discrimination, best interests of the child, a holistic approach to human rights and the right to voice.

How can we strengthen the international protection of children’s rights? First, universalisation of ratification, especially the optional protocols, reinforcing the protection of children’s rights as a powerful tool. Second, mainstreaming a gender perspective. This is needed to advance gender equality. Third, incorporate an intersectional approach. Fourth, extending and reinforcing accountability to private actors. And finally, we have to incorporate children’s rights into climate governance and litigation.


This is an abridged version of ‘The world and its children: the grave legal challenges to protecting the wellbeing and rights of the child’ session. The filmed session can be viewed in full here.