LPD Showcase: how AI is reinventing the legal profession
As part of the IBA Legal Practice Division showcase session, a panel of law firm leaders explored how organisations are responding to artificial intelligence and assessed the potential impact on the profession over the next five to ten years.
Charles Martin, Senior Advisor, Darrois Villey (CM): Can members of the panel tell us how they’re adapting to the use of artificial intelligence?
Alan Mason, Global Managing Partner, Freshfields: We are not approaching AI in a vacuum or looking at AI as being something separate from the firm’s strategy. Interestingly, the legal market, at the ‘big law’ end at least, is going through a very significant period of disruption anyway, regardless of AI. So, we are not seeing AI come along and impact a static industry. And that’s very much how we’re approaching it. We’re thinking about how the industry is evolving anyway, what role do we want to play in the industry going forward and the impact of AI on that. We see it as an opportunity to evolve more quickly and we’re approaching our AI strategy from that respect.
What AI has forced us to do though – and it’s a good thing – is look at our strategy or at what it means to be a law firm today, and what we’re actually doing for our clients, and, to a large extent, question what we are the best placed to deliver.
If you think about the various components of what makes up the legal industry or what it requires in order to deliver legal services today, up until now everything has been delivered by external counsel to in-house counsel in a very generic, packaged way. What we’ve been doing is trying to unpack the various components of what we need to deliver legal services. There are four parts to it – in an AI world, at least – that we’ve identified so far. First of all, what models do you need? Then what data do we have? What software do we add on? And then what services are we delivering? So, if we unpack the market in that way, we can then decide as a firm which part of the market we really want to play in and adapt our strategy accordingly.
So – no surprises – we are not going to compete against Big Tech for any of the models. We do think we’ve got some pretty awesome data that we’re trying to think about how we can share and monetise directly to our clients. We’re not a software company either, but we need to integrate software. And of course, we are very focused therefore on the legal services that we are providing.
The legal market, at the ‘big law’ end at least, is going through a very significant period of disruption. So we are not seeing AI come along and impact a static industry
Alan Mason
Global Managing Partner, Freshfields
What that has forced us to do is really rethink not only our business model, but also our relationship with other market players – sometimes we’re competing with some of these players, and sometimes we’re cooperating with them. We’ve entered into some strategic partnerships, designed to share out the skills or work with parties who we think are best-placed to service our clients.
We’re developing workflows and skills through these partnerships, but I would say that none of that really matters because for every day we develop a new skill or a workflow, another firm or another tech company is out there developing the same thing, or something different, something better, to address the same underlying issue or objective that we have. So, the key thing we are absolutely focused on is adoption. We are trying to re-engineer the law firm as we run it day-to-day to think about how we need to be integrating new ways of working in everything that we’re doing – be it the services we’re offering our clients, new services, how we’re transforming the industry, how we’re recruiting, how we’re training, how we’re marketing to our clients. It’s a very fundamental rethink of the law firm.
Wai King Ng, Chairman and Senior Partner, WongPartnership: Adoption of AI is a key strategy for the firm that has been front and centre for the last two years, in the sense that we have made a top-down decision to drive this across the firm, making sure that the partners understand why AI adoption is an important part of how we deliver services to clients. At a more practical level, we’ve taken the view for the last ten years that we are not software engineers by training, but lawyers by training. Therefore, trying to build and maintain a platform that competes with Harvey and Legora, for example, was not going to be the way we would adopt technology. So, we made a conscious decision that we would buy ‘off the shelf’. We would adapt. We would work with the vendors. We would try and figure out how best to provide a solution that our lawyers can use very quickly.
We’ve been very upfront to clients in terms of our governance around AI. It’s publicly available. We tell them how we’re using it. And the conversation with clients over the last two years has been very interesting in terms of the deployment of AI. A year ago, the conversations around requests for proposals, on work with clients, included lots of issues relating to AI. Financial institutions, particularly, had reservations about the use of AI. That has changed – the conversation is very different. I think clients expect that as a law firm we will be using AI. Obviously, there is the expectation that we must use AI responsibly and also that there is a cost that we will, in a sense, share with them as we think about how this benefits the client overall.
A year ago, very few clients were embracing technology the way we would have liked them to. Very few of them were talking about AI software, and we had sessions in the office showing them the different tools and what can be done. This year, it’s fair to say that, at least in Singapore, every other client either has or is trialling an AI tool. It’s clear that clients today are savvier about technology than they were 12 months ago. So that shift in terms of where clients are moving is, to me, a wake-up call – if clients have the same tools that we have, or maybe even better tools than we have, it has to make us very careful about how we think about technology and how we deliver our legal services to the client.
There’s an obligation on us as a profession to be advocates for the rule of law, for the role of lawyers, in this next phase
Renae Lattey
Chief Executive Partner, Australia, Mallesons
CM: This next section focuses on the longer term, on the future.
Renae Lattey, Chief Executive Partner, Australia, Mallesons (RL): I am optimistic about the future. I’ve been spending a lot of time on the people-related issues for what comes next, thinking about how we recruit differently and how we train people. The incentives and the remuneration, for example – our system is still built around the billable hour, and so it requires thinking very carefully about how you change that so the incentives are the right incentives as we move to a system where you are not billing your clients quite as much in that way. These things need a lot of deep thought by organisations. On the client front, there are real opportunities for us all to work closely with clients in redesigning how we supply legal services to them.
I also think that we’re all under an obligation to make this profession still an exciting one for people to enter into. You might not think that lawyers are going to be here forever, but there is still trust and legal intelligence that’s going to be required to make sure that the AI agents that are being created are running the way that you expect them to be running, at least for a period. So doing exciting things with clients is a really good way to encourage our younger lawyers that there is a future for them in this industry. It might not look exactly the same as it has looked for each of us in our careers, but there are certainly going to be new jobs for the lawyers to be doing.
The last point is that there’s an obligation on us as a profession to be advocates for the rule of law, for the role of lawyers, in this next phase, and for good judgement, good decision-making and trust in organisations. If you assume that democracy is still going to exist in the future and that institutions are going to exist, then you are going to need good governance, good decision-making and auditability of all of that.
Isabel Parker, Chief Innovation Officer, White & Case (IP): I get very excited when I listen to Alan, for example, describe the future law firm. I can see it. I like the idea of it. But I do think, who’s going to build it? We have talked a lot on this panel about lawyers and very little about anybody else. And actually, who are the people that are going to build this new world? I’m not sure it’s just the lawyers. I think it’s the systems thinkers, the AI engineers, the legal engineers, the knowledge engineers.
When I joined White & Case two years ago, I was under pressure to expand out my very small innovation team, because people kept telling me that the lawyers haven’t got time to do this themselves – they’re all brilliant, but they’re too time-constrained, so we need to build out a big support network. I really resisted that, because I thought, ‘this is the job now, let’s just really push our lawyers to get there’. But over time, I have seen that the transition is taking a long time. People are curious and smart, but they don’t have time to experiment, to learn, to tinker. So currently we are having to shore up that capability with a lot of roles that sit around the edges – legal engineers, knowledge engineers, AI architects, and so on.
If you spend your time thinking about what other firms are doing, it’s an utter waste of energy and you can’t afford to waste time because you’ve got to act now
Isabel Parker
Chief Innovation Officer, White & Case
The question for everyone who’s interested in operations is: are these permanent roles forever? Are these transitory roles that fall away, like prompt engineers fell away and became something else? How deeply do you want to invest in that? How deeply do you want to invest in upskilling your lawyers themselves to build this brave new world? If we think about who is the highest paid and most lauded in the legal profession, it’s undoubtedly the rainmakers, some of the lateral partners that you hear about with eye-watering amounts of money paid for their – I have no doubt – substantial and brilliant judgement and expertise. But if we do buy into a world where you can encode expertise into a skill and apply it through AI, you have to question whether that’s really sustainable, and should we be looking beyond that narrow lens to a broader set of capabilities and skills – non-lawyer skills – that we bring into our organisations to build this new world? That’s how I would see it.
CM: Can panel members offer one piece of advice to the audience?
RL: Get your hands dirty. I made all of my leadership team do some work off our systems with Claude and ChatGPT to just make sure we all understood what the agents were capable of today. That has changed the way that I have been able to speak about it and the way the leadership team understands the challenge ahead of us. So, I think that getting your hands dirty is really important.
IP: Don’t waste time obsessing about what other law firms are doing. It’s irrelevant. You have to work out what’s best for your clients, what outcomes they want. If you spend your time thinking about what other firms are doing, it’s an utter waste of energy and you can’t afford to waste time because you’ve got to act now.
This is an abridged version of part of the session, ‘LPD Showcase: the future is now – how AI is reinventing the legal profession’. Watch the full session here.
The ‘big picture’ and the ‘client picture’
The session also featured two further parts - the ‘big picture’ and the ‘client picture’ - both available to watch here.
The first was an overview of where artificial intelligence has come from, and how it’s currently reshaping legal practice, provided by Richard Susskind CBE. The final session offered client perspectives on how AI is reshaping the economics, dynamics and trust architecture of legal services, examined through the lived experience of general counsel navigating transformations within their own organisations. The panel for this session consisted of Kasper Friis-Hansen, Group General Counsel at Danske Bank; Yuto Matsumura, Chief Legal Officer and General Counsel at Hitachi; Marianna Nitsch, Global Chief Legal Officer and Company Secretary at Chanel; and Maria Pernas, General Counsel and Commercial and Contract Management at Capgemini.