Luxury asset structuring on the Moon

Wednesday 18 November 2026

Report on a session at the IBA Annual Conference 2026 in Copenhagen, held on 6 October 2026

Session Co-Chairs

Katharina Binder, DORDA, Vienna
Michael Rutili, Stephenson Harwood, London; Conference Quality Officer, IBA Private Client Tax Committee

Panellists

Ouri Belmin, Tirard Naudin, Paris
Marta Gracia Domenech, Garrigues, Arganda del Rey
George McCormick, BakerHostetler, New York

Reporter

Aakash Mishra, Shreya Rao & Associates, Bangalore

Introduction

Luxury assets often begin as personal purchases and later become investments or family property. Michael Rutili described the familiar client request as wanting ‘the moon on a stick’ – advice on tax, ownership and estate planning, delivered quickly enough to complete a coveted purchase. The session considered how advisers can respond when the asset is a home, art collection, yacht, private aircraft or vineyard and the family has connections with several countries.

The discussion kept returning to one practical point – the legal owner tells only part of the story. The adviser also needs to know who will use the asset, where it will be kept, whether it will earn income and what should happen to it on the owner’s demise.

Use matters as much as ownership

Marta Gracia Domenech explained that an efficient investment structure may produce a different tax result once a shareholder or family member uses the asset personally. Location adds another layer. A yacht may spend winter in Spain and summer in France, art may move between residences and an aircraft may enter several tax and registration systems. Each move may trigger consequences under VAT, registration taxes, wealth taxes and reporting obligations.

Valuation is also less straightforward than it is for assets like listed securities. Appraisals may differ with timing and purpose. Many luxury assets are indivisible, illiquid and emotionally important to the family, which can make an eventual division between beneficiaries cumbersome.

Ouri Belmin traced these issues within the usual analysis for tangible property – namely, legal ownership, intended use, the location of the asset, the residence of the beneficial owner and the relevant succession law. French tax rules also distinguish sharply between real estate and movable property. Belmin referred to a measure in France’s 2026 Finance Act concerning certain assets held through private holding companies, including cars, yachts, private aircraft, jewellery and racehorses.

George McCormick added that a cross-border structure may require advice in every country it touches. A US client buying a European home may need US advice, including advice where the property is located and advice from the country in which a company or trust is established. The residence of each beneficiary may introduce further jurisdictions. US classification of a foreign foundation, company or trust must also be checked rather than assumed.

Current investment trends

McCormick has seen more US clients explore property and financial holdings outside the country during the past two years. Their enquiries include European property, second passports, long-term residence options and Swiss bank accounts. In his opinion, the motivation is a combination of economic and political diversification and asset protection. Some clients are also considering rural land and ranches in Western Canada, New Zealand, Argentina and Uruguay.

Belmin described France as a steady inbound market, particularly for real estate. Transactions could range from a Paris apartment bought in the individual’s name to large properties held through commercial structures and let with hotel-like services. A commercial structure may support expense deductions and VAT recovery where the facts justify that treatment, although it does not solve issues relating to French inheritance, gift or wealth taxes.

Vineyards show how personal enjoyment, commercial activity and succession planning can meet in one asset. Belmin discussed a Burgundy Premier Cru plot acquired through a structure linked to a trust for the buyer’s children. A separate operating company, involving professional winemakers, handled the commercial business. Gracia Domenech noted growing interest in vineyards in Spain as well, while highlighting that these assets require specialist management and may take time to sell. Spanish luxury investment remains centred on apartments in Madrid and Barcelona and villas in the Balearic Islands and Marbella.

One family and four assets

The co-chairs tested the issues through a case study involving a US entrepreneur who had sold an artificial intelligence business. He wanted a Paris apartment, a Mallorca villa, a yacht based in the Mediterranean and an art collection. He was married, had three adult children living in different countries and wanted the family to enjoy the assets while preserving them for future generations. Privacy was also important.

McCormick’s first recommendation was to seek coordinated advice before signing or buying. Income tax, estate or inheritance tax, sales tax, VAT and registration rules may all affect the acquisition. Local planning can also disturb an existing succession plan. A will prepared for a newly acquired foreign property may revoke (or appear to revoke) a carefully negotiated will in the home country. Forced heirship and the residence of beneficiaries also require attention simultaneously.

When a company creates problems

Gracia Domenech addressed a common assumption that a company is the natural owner of every luxury asset. In Spain, personal use by a shareholder or relative without payment of market rent may be treated as remuneration in kind or a deemed dividend. The arrangement can also lead to non-deductible VAT. Where a company has no genuine business purpose, the tax authority may disregard it and attribute the asset to the concerned individual. A Spanish company may expose its shareholder to wealth tax, and a foreign company whose assets primarily consist of Spanish real estate may produce a similar result.

Direct ownership may suit a property intended mainly for family use, provided that the residence and succession issues are managed. Wills, co-ownership arrangements and family agreements may address those concerns. Where a company is used, commercial activity should be genuine and supported by evidence, such as third party letting, suitable management and proper substance.

Belmin gave a comparable caution for France. The tax transparency of a US limited liability company or an S corporation may not be recognised in France, with possible corporate tax consequences. A foreign trust may be treated as transparent for inheritance and gift tax and as opaque for income tax. He also cautioned against placing every asset in one company. Separate vehicles may help isolate assets and limit the reach of reporting duties, while French rules can still treat shares in a company holding mainly French real estate as French assets.

US owners of foreign companies and trusts face extensive reporting. McCormick noted that a failure to report a foreign trust can attract a penalty based on the value contributed even where the trust is otherwise tax neutral. Any foreign vehicle, consequently, needs to fit the US reporting regime as well as the rules where the asset is located.

Privacy after anonymity

The panellists accepted that complete anonymity is rarely realistic. In France, foreign trust reporting can require disclosure of the settlor, beneficiaries and trust assets. The French three per cent real estate tax can be avoided by making the required disclosure of the ownership chain. French companies are also subject to beneficial ownership reporting. A client using an existing trust for a French investment may therefore expose more of the trust to French reporting than anticipated. A separate structure may sometimes narrow that effect.

Spanish real estate ownership is recorded in a public land registry. Corporate structures are subject to beneficial ownership disclosure, and Spanish tax residents must report specified foreign assets through Form 720. The US presents a less uniform picture. McCormick described limited ownership information in Delaware, more disclosure in some other states and extensive public real estate records in places such as New York City and certain parts of Florida.

He also discussed the increased use of self-settled asset protection trusts in some US states that permit them. Such a trust may protect a settlor who is also a beneficiary once statutory conditions and waiting periods are met. It cannot be used to defeat known creditors, and the protection may not work where the relevant asset is located in a state that does not recognise the arrangement. A Nevada trust, for example, may offer little protection for New York real estate.

Trusts in France and Spain

Belmin explained that France has had a tax framework for foreign trusts since 2011. Trusts are generally treated as transparent for inheritance, gift and wealth tax and as opaque for income tax. An existing trust can often be accommodated; however, it does not remove French tax or reporting. The structure may need a company beneath the trust to hold French real estate and allow registration of legal title.

Spain takes a different approach. Gracia Domenech said that Spanish civil and tax law do not recognise trusts as separate arrangements. The authorities examine the terms and actual operation of the trust and may attribute the assets to the settlor, where disposal powers remain, or to the beneficiaries according to their rights of enjoyment. The result depends on the facts of the concerned trust.

Closing observations

The panel closed by correcting three recurring misconceptions: (1) company ownership does not make personal use tax efficient; (2) a high-tax country need not be ruled out before the client’s purpose and the available planning have been examined; and (3) a structure that works in one jurisdiction cannot be carried into another without checking its local classification and reporting consequences.

The final practical reminder concerned the family itself. Rutili cautioned against assuming that children and grandchildren will share the owner’s attachment to a house, vineyard, yacht or car collection. Before building a structure intended to last for generations, advisers should ask how the asset will be used, who genuinely wants it and how maintenance, decision-making and an eventual sale will be handled.