Non-trial Resolutions of Bribery Cases Subcommittee

Thursday 3 August 2023

Introduction

While once fairly rare, now over 80% of foreign bribery cases are resolved through negotiated settlements or other so-called “non-trial resolutions” (“NTRs”). That percentage is growing as more and more countries accept, formally or informally, the desirability of resolving complex and costly foreign bribery investigations through NTRs. In 2018, the IBA published a global study showing that most countries around the world that enforce their foreign bribery laws use some form of negotiated settlement or non-trial resolution to resolve international bribery cases before a full trial and verdict. However, in many countries, there is no formal or transparent framework in place regarding how and when non-trial resolutions are used, leading to confusion, inequitable outcomes, and a lack of transparency for both companies, enforcement authorities and the public.

Lawyers and corporations have tried for years to address this. The international private bar, including the IBA, played a key role in encouraging the OECD to adopt guidelines for NTRs, which the OECD did in their 2021 Recommendations.

International guidelines for non-trial resolutions (NTRs) of foreign bribery cases

On 26 November 2021, the OECD issued its Recommendation of the Council for OECD Legal Instruments Further Combating Bribery of Foreign Public Officials in International Business Transactions. These Recommendations are the first set of international guidelines for the successful use of NTRs, and will have a significant effect on the investigation, prosecution, and resolution of international bribery cases around the world.

The Recommendations provide detailed guidance on best practices for the use of NTRs, including requiring that countries prioritize clarity and transparency in how NTRs are structured, the criteria applied to determine when NTRs are appropriate, and how enforcement will be carried out. Additionally, the OECD’s recommendations emphasize that NTRs should be public and should not serve as an obstacle to effective investigation of misconduct or to the prosecution of other potentially culpable persons, either natural or legal.

Project Roll Out

Project Roll Out is an effort by the International Bar Association to encourage the adoption of NTRs for international corruption case across the world. Find out more about Project Roll Out and how you can help here. Those interested in participating in Project Roll Out should contact Kara Novaco Brockmeyer, Chair, or Tom Best, Vice Chair, of the Non-trial Resolutions of Bribery Cases Subcommittee.

Find out more

Non-trial Resolutions of Bribery Cases Subcommittee

Thomas Richard Best

Co-Chair

Firm Address
Paul Hastings 2050 M Street, N.W.
Washington
USA
20036
Kara Novaco Brockmeyer

Co-Chair

Firm Address
Debevoise & Plimpton LLP 801 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W
Washington
USA
20004
Diego Sierra

Vice Chair

Firm Address
Von Wobeser & Sierra Paseo de los Tamarindos 60
Bosques de Las Lomas
Mexico City
Mexico
05120
Sabine Stetter

Vice Chair

Firm Address
stetter Rechtsanwälte Amiraplatz 3
Munich
Germany
80333
Karla Lini Maeji

Secretary

Firm Address
TozziniFreire Advogados Rua Borges Lagoa 1328
Vila Clementino
São Paulo
Brazil
04038-904
Thiago Jabor Pinheiro

Regional Representative Latin America

Firm Address
Mattos Filho Al Joaquim Eugênio de Lima 447
Jardim Paulista
São Paulo
Brazil
01403-001
Jeena Kim

Rapporteur

Firm Address
Bae Kim & Lee Centropolis B,
26 Ujeongguk-ro, Jongno-gu,
Seoul
South Korea
03161
Jianwei Jerry Fang

Regional Representative Asia General

Firm Address
Zhong Lun Law Firm 6/10/11/16/17F, Two IFC
8 Century Avenue
Pudong New Area
Shanghai
China
200120
Thomas Helck

Regional Representative Europe

Firm Address
HELCK Legal Ludwigstr. 8
Munich
Germany
80539
James Raymond Newland Jr

Regional Representative North America

Firm Address
Seyfarth Shaw 975 F St NW
Washington
USA
20004-1405